Inconsistencies and material facts
Examine the points of tension that prompted the instruction, without treating suspicion as a conclusion.
When records, representations or observed events do not align, we organise the facts around the decision that needs to be made. We consider what is appropriately accessible, whether different sources support the same account and which questions remain open. The point is not simply to identify a discrepancy, but to understand its context and materiality.
The scope should distinguish decision-relevant issues from background detail. We make source, date and context visible so a reader can assess the basis for each observation. Where information cannot be independently established, that uncertainty remains part of the account.
